When the Supreme Court issues a plurality opinion, it means that:

Question

Accepted Answer

The majority agrees on the outcome but not on a single legal rationale. A plurality opinion occurs when a majority of justices agree on the outcome of a case (which side wins) but cannot agree on a single legal rationale for that outcome. In this situation, the opinion joined by the most justices  -  but fewer than a majority  -  is called the plurality opinion. While the judgment of the Court is binding on the parties, the plurality's reasoning does not carry the same precedential weight as a majority opinion because it does not represent the views of a majority of the Court.

A unanimous opinion, not a plurality, describes a situation where all justices agree on both the outcome and reasoning. If the Court sends a case back to a lower court, that is called a remand, which is a procedural disposition rather than a type of opinion. While the plurality opinion is written by fewer than a majority of justices, it still represents the largest bloc among the majority  -  it is not a minority opinion, as the plurality's side won the case.

In plurality decisions, courts and legal scholars often look to the narrowest concurring opinion as the controlling rationale, following the approach established in Marks v. United States (1977). For example, in Regents of the University of California v. Bakke (1978), Justice Powell's opinion was the controlling one because it represented the narrowest ground on which five justices could agree. Plurality decisions can create uncertainty in the law because lower courts must interpret which reasoning to follow. Understanding the different types of Supreme Court opinions  -  majority, plurality, concurring, and dissenting  -  is important for the CLEP exam because it reveals how the Court's decision-making process works in practice.

CLEP American Government: Question of the Day

Get a free CLEP American Government question every day

Ready for the full CLEP American Government? Earn 3 college credits.