Which type of evidence is generally considered strongest in academic argument?

Question

Accepted Answer

Expert testimony and peer-reviewed research. The correct answer is expert testimony and peer-reviewed research. In academic writing, evidence from qualified experts and research that has been vetted through the peer review process carries the most weight. This evidence is considered reliable because it has been subjected to scrutiny by other experts in the field and follows established research methodologies.

Personal anecdotes provide vivid illustration but are limited in scope (one person's experience may not be representative) and carry less authority in academic contexts. Dictionary definitions are useful for establishing precise meanings but do not constitute evidence for an argument. Hypothetical examples can illustrate a point but lack the persuasive power of real evidence because they describe what could happen, not what has happened.

Understanding the hierarchy of evidence is crucial for the CLEP exam. Students should know that peer-reviewed studies and expert analysis are at the top, followed by empirical data, credible journalistic sources, and then personal experience and anecdote. The type of evidence appropriate may vary by discipline and context, but academic writing generally values evidence that is verifiable, representative, and reviewed by experts.

CLEP College Composition: Question of the Day

Get a free CLEP College Composition question every day

Ready for the full CLEP College Composition? Earn 6 college credits.