What is "digital redlining" and how does it relate to the digital divide?

Question

Accepted Answer

The practice whereby ISPs and technology companies provide inferior service or fewer options to low-income and minority communities, mirroring historical housing discrimination. Digital redlining refers to the practice whereby internet service providers and technology companies provide inferior services, fewer options, slower speeds, or higher prices to communities based on their socioeconomic or racial composition, mirroring the historical practice of redlining in which banks and insurers denied services to neighborhoods based on race. Research has documented cases where ISPs offer slower speeds and fewer service options in low-income and predominantly minority neighborhoods compared to more affluent areas, even when the cost of service deployment is similar. This practice perpetuates and deepens the digital divide along existing lines of social and economic inequality.

Marking important passages in digital textbooks with red highlighting describes a study technique or annotation feature in educational software that has no connection to discriminatory service provision. Editing digital photographs to remove red-eye effects describes a photo editing function that is entirely unrelated to the concept of discriminatory technology service delivery. Flagging inappropriate content on social media with red warning labels describes a content moderation visual indicator, not a pattern of discriminatory service provision based on community demographics.

Digital redlining is an advanced concept that connects technology ethics to social justice and may appear on the Ethics in Technology exam. Students should understand how this practice parallels historical housing discrimination, the evidence documenting it, its impact on already disadvantaged communities, and the policy and regulatory responses aimed at ensuring equitable technology access. Understanding this concept demonstrates sophisticated knowledge of how technology intersects with systemic inequality.

DSST Ethics in Technology: Question of the Day

Get a free DSST Ethics in Technology question every day

Ready for the full DSST Ethics in Technology? Earn 3 college credits.